Section 50 of Income Tax Act

Section 50 of the Income Tax Act deals with the computation of capital gains on the sale of depreciable assets. It outlines the rules for calculating capital gains on assets that have been depreciated over time.

Section 50 (1) of the Income Tax Act stipulates that the difference between the sale consideration and the Written Down Value (WDV) of the assets is considered a short-term capital gain.

The Union Budget of 2024 introduced several key amendments to Section 50 of the Income Tax Act. The newly introduced changes primarily impact the classification and taxation of long-term and short-term capital gain on depreciable assets.

The updates are to be in effect from the financial year 2024-2025 to streamline asset categorisation and provide more flexible options for taxpayers.

-Holding Period Changes

The 2024 update introduced a change in the holding period for capital gains tax purposes with now only two holding periods in place for the classification of assets.

• Short-term capital gains (STCG): Assets held for less than 12 months.

• Long-term capital gains (LTCG): Assets held for more than 12 months.

Under this new change, any depreciable assets held for more than 12 months will now be considered long-term capital assets.

-Tax Rates on Long-term Capital Gains

As per the new budget update, the tax rate on long-term capital gains from the sale of depreciable assets has been reduced from 20 % to 12.5 %. A major change is the removal of the indexation benefit, which was previously used to adjust the cost of acquisition to account for inflation.

Taxpayers involved in real estate transactions for properties acquired before this date will have the option to either pay the reduced rate of 12.5% without indexation or the standard rate of 20% with indexation. This flexibility allows taxpayers to compute their taxes and choose the method that minimises their tax liability.

-Tax Rates on Short-term Capital Gains

The 2024 budget has also introduced revisions to short-term capital gain tax rates, particularly impacting financial and non-financial assets. Short-term capital gain tax on stocks and other specified financial assets will now be charged at a uniform rate of 20%.

Meanwhile, short-term gains on other non-financial assets, such as depreciable business assets or other property held for less than 24 months, will be taxed according to the taxpayer’s applicable income tax slab rates.

While the STCG tax rate on equity has been increased to 20%, for certain investment instruments like unlisted bonds, debentures, debt mutual funds and market-linked debentures, short-term capital gains will be taxed at applicable rates regardless of the holding period.

Depreciable assets are long-term assets that lose their value over time due to wear and tear, usage or obsolescence. These assets include vehicles, machinery, office equipment, computers and real estate (excluding land).

The reduction in value of such assets is termed depreciation, which can be claimed as a tax deduction under the Income Tax Act. This concept allows taxpayers to offset the decline in an asset’s value to align its book value with its actual market worth.

A block of assets, as defined by Section 50 (1) of the Income Tax Act, is a grouping of depreciable assets within the same class. These depreciable assets are categorised by their similar nature, usage and prescribed depreciation rates.

Assets in a block share identical depreciation rates and are systematically organised based on their characteristics. This includes both tangible assets, such as buildings, machinery, plants and furniture as well as intangible assets like patents, copyrights, trademarks and licences.

Depreciation is computed on each block based on its Written Down Value (WDV). Written Down Value represents the cumulative value of assets in the block at the end of the financial year after accounting for depreciation. Additionally, the Written Down Value of a block can never assume a negative value.

When assets within a block are sold, the capital gain or loss depends on factors like the number of assets transferred and whether the sale proceeds exceed the Written Down Value. Any gain or loss resulting from the sale of depreciable assets in a block is treated as a short-term capital gain or loss.

To calculate capital gain on the partial transfer of depreciable assets within a block, some specific rules under Section 50 (1) of the Income Tax Act need to be applied. Here is a breakdown of the process:

Scenario 1: Where Sale Reduces the Block’s Written Down Value to Zero

After deducting any selling expenses, when the sale consideration from a transferred asset is subtracted from the block’s Written Down Value (WDV), inclusive of any new acquisitions and this reduction brings the WDV to zero, a short-term capital gain arises. In this case, the entire proceeds are treated as short-term capital gain.

-For example :

-**Sale Consideration: ₹15,000

-**Opening of WDV of Block: ₹12,000

-**Cost of newly acquired assets: ₹600

Short-term capital gain = ₹15,000 - ( ₹12,000 + ₹600) = ₹2,400

Scenario 2: Where Sale Does Not Reduce the Block’s Written Down Value to Zero

If the sale consideration does not reduce the block’s Written Down Value (WDV) to zero, no capital gain or loss is recognised. Instead, depreciation is calculated and allowed on the remaining Written Down Value for the next financial year.

The calculation of capital gain or loss when all assets in a block are transferred follows specific guidelines under Section 50 of the Income Tax Act of 1961. Here is a breakdown of the process:

**Scenario 1: Where Sale Consideration Exceeds the Block’s Written Down Value

If the total sale proceeds from all assets in a block exceed the block’s Written Down Value (WDV), including any new acquisitions, the difference is recognised as a short-term capital gain.

For example:

Sale Consideration: ₹50,000

Opening Written Down Value of the Block: ₹30,000

Cost of newly acquired assets: ₹6,000

Short-term capital gain = ₹50,000 - ( ₹30,000 + ₹6,000 ) = ₹14,000

This gain is taxable in the same financial year as a short-term capital gain.

Scenario 2: Where Sale Consideration Falls Short of the Block’s Written Down Value

When the sale consideration for all assets in a block is lower than the block’s Written Down Value (WDV), the difference results in a short-term capital loss.

For example:

• Opening Written Down Value of the Block: ₹60,000

• Cost of newly acquired assets: ₹12,000

• Sale Consideration: ₹30,000

• Short-term capital gain = ( ₹60,000 + ₹12,000 ) - ₹30,000 = ₹42,000

• No depreciation will be allowed on the block if a loss is recognised.

Filing Requirements

Whether there is a short-term capital gain or loss, filing an Income Tax Return (IR) is mandatory for compliance and recording of capital transactions. Calculations ensure accurate tax treatment on the sale of depreciable assets which provide clarity in asset management and tax planning.

Section 50 of the Income Tax Act plays a significant role in determining the tax implications on depreciable assets and ensures that capital gains and losses are accurately accounted for. The recent updates in the 2024 Budget, with revised tax rates, holding periods and flexible options, offer taxpayers the ability to optimise their tax liabilities more effectively.

Understanding the nuances of calculating capital gains, whether from partial or complete asset transfers within a block, is essential for taxpayers, businesses and professionals managing larger portfolios of depreciable assets.

With careful tax planning and adherence to the guidelines of Section 50 of the Income Tax Act, taxpayers can enhance financial transparency, comply with tax obligations and maximise the benefits of asset management strategies.

Just as Section 50 of the Income Tax Act provides benefits for tax calculations, Section 80 D of the Income Tax Act offers valuable tax reliefs when you invest in a health insurance plan. However, beyond tax advantages, investing in medical insurance shields you from the financial impact of rising health risks of the modern lifestyle and the ongoing medical inflation in India.

Choosing a trusted provider like TATA AIG ensures quality, reliability and comprehensive care in your health insurance plan. With TATA AIG’s low-premium health insurance option, you are safeguarded by an array of benefits. Our health insurance policy includes coverage for expensive consumables used during treatment, the Worldwide Cover for overseas medical treatment and OPD Cover to manage yearly medical consultation costs.

For expecting families, the maternity and newborn covers offer essential support, while the automatic restoration feature refills your sum insured in case of emergencies. Additionally, you can earn up to a 100% cumulative bonus on your sum insured for every claim-free year, which enhances your coverage without raising premiums.

TATA AIG’s seamless claim process, backed by over 650+ experts, makes managing your health insurance policy hassle-free. With such benefits, investing in a TATA AIG health insurance plan means securing your health with quality coverage.

-Does Section 50 C apply to depreciable assets?

Section 50 C applies to capital assets, including depreciable property that is classified as land or building.

-What distinguishes Section 50 C from Section 43 CA?

Section 50 C applies to capital assets, while Section 43 CA is for business assets, affecting business income.

-When does the new capital gains rule from the Finance Bill take effect?

The new capital gains apply to transactions made on or after July 23, 2024.

Can taxpayers still access rollover benefits on capital gains?**

Yes, taxpayers can still access rollover benefits for eligible long-term gains.

-How does Section 50 of the Income Tax Act handle capital gain on depreciable assets?

Section 50 of the Income Tax Act categorises all capital gains on depreciable assets as short-term capital gains, regardless of holding period.

-How do we compute gains or losses when all assets in a block are sold?

If sale proceeds exceed the Written Down Value of the block, there is a short-term gain. If the sale proceeds fall short, it results in a short-term loss.

-How has the asset holding period changed under the new rules introduced in the budget for 2024?

The holding period is now two years for most assets and one year for listed securities.

-What is the updated rate for STT-paid capital assets under the new budget for 2024?

Short-term rates on STT-paid assets rose from 15% to 20% and long-term rates rose from 10% to 12.5%.

-Who would benefit from the 12.5% rate on assets without indexation that was introduced under the new budget for 2024?

Most taxpayers would benefit from the 12.5% rate on assets without indexation that was introduced under the new budget for 2024, except in cases with minimal gain relative to inflation.

-Can depreciation be claimed on sold or destroyed assets?

No, depreciation cannot be claimed on assets that were sold or destroyed within the financial year.